Items marked with * incur extra charges which are payable locally.
Reviews
Tripadvisor Traveller RatingBased on 17067 Reviews
Traveller ReviewsRanked #326 of 582 hotels in New York City
Traveller Rating
Excellent
5901
Very Good
6427
Average
2826
Poor
1061
Terrible
853
Rating Summary
Location
Sleep Quality
Rooms
Service
Value
Cleanliness
Bader A said...
Outstanding Service from DeMarcus
Travelled on 01/2026
I want to give a special shout-out to DeMarcus for making my first visit to New York an excellent experience. From the moment I arrived, he was professional, welcoming, and genuinely attentive. He carries himself with a great attitude and clearly takes pride in his work, which really shows in how he treats guests.
DeMarcus went above and beyond to make sure everything was smooth and comfortable, and he did it effort...
Read more
Katie W said...
Great hotel - great location
Travelled on 01/2026
Rooms a little dated but very clean. Fresh towels and bed made dailys. All staff very friendly and helpful. Great location as very close to penn subway station. We will definitely return when coming to New York again....
Coastal45049726857 said...
Shopping trip
Travelled on 01/2026
I have stayed in the New Yorker some twenty years ago at that time my experience about the hotel was excellent this time around my experience was far from memorable it seems the hotel was in a time warp hasnt been upgraded at all lets start with the check in we had a chap called Mohammad who was rude and arrogant totally un helpful kept on about he has been there for twenty five years getting to the room itself ver...
Read more
robertwilliamf said...
Great location
Travelled on 01/2026
Great location on 34th Street, near train station and subway which saved us a fortune on Taxi fares to and from Airport. Great for shopping as Macys and Hudson Yards are within walking distance....
betsa122 said...
Best Hotel Ever--but not for everyone
Travelled on 01/2026
The New Yorker is not for everyone, but it is for me. I've stayed in hundreds of hotels around the world, and the front desk staff at the New Yorker are the very best. I'm especially grateful to Linda, Krystie, Mohammed and Driss, who consistently go above and beyond. Second to the staff are the views. Spectacular!! Some rooms even have balconies--not a consideration for January, but I've stayed in the summer as w...
Read more