Items marked with * incur extra charges which are payable locally.
Reviews
Tripadvisor Traveller RatingBased on 8695 Reviews
Traveller ReviewsRanked #62 of 586 hotels in New York City
Traveller Rating
Excellent
6381
Very Good
1391
Average
492
Poor
225
Terrible
211
Rating Summary
Location
Sleep Quality
Rooms
Service
Value
Cleanliness
Robert Z said...
Excellent staff
Travelled on 06/2026
Betty at the front desk was very helpful, Gania in the restaurant was an excellent waitress.
Both were personable, professional, knowledgeable and a pleasure to interact with throughout our stay....
Robin R said...
Great location and hotel
Travelled on 06/2026
Great location and beautiful room. Staff was wonderful! The internet is slow...we were there during World Cup and NBA playoffs, so that may have been part of the problem. We have stayed here twice....
Giovannibelo said...
Great great great
Travelled on 06/2026
This hotel was an incredible experience - we had to change from another one nearby that was charging a similar price, but was very low quality. The Knickerbocker was outstanding, clean and safe, the staff was amazing, and the fact that they keep your room clean and organized was a plus. Shoutout to Gania in the 4th floor restaurant, she was very nice and was always making sure we had everything we needed during break...
Read more
paulamazanek said...
Perfect stay!
Travelled on 06/2026
Lovely hotel in a great location. Mrs. Gania was a true gem wonderfully friendly service at the restaurant....
baeason said...
Business trip
Travelled on 06/2026
Great stay. Clean. Well located. Kind staff. Great breakfast. A wonderful woman named Gania was a delight to meet at breakfast each day. The personal services means so much. I will be back...