Items marked with * incur extra charges which are payable locally.
Reviews
Tripadvisor Traveller RatingBased on 7813 Reviews
Traveller ReviewsRanked #84 of 560 hotels in New York City
Traveller Rating
Excellent
5644
Very Good
1292
Average
464
Poor
217
Terrible
196
Rating Summary
Location
Sleep Quality
Rooms
Service
Value
Cleanliness
Sarah M said...
One of my fav hotels in NYC!
Travelled on 05/2025
Comfortable and generous sized rooms! Fantastic location and very attentive staff. Excellent space and the bathroom and storage in the rooms were plentiful. The coffee bar in the hotel was very fast. The gym had two different areas and were very clean and well equipped....
Sara G said...
Excellent couple weekend- 50th birthday
Travelled on 05/2025
Overall what an excellent stay! For NYC, the room was huge and quiet and clean with a super comfy bed. We were on a waitlist for a room upgrade and we got it! The staff at the Knickerbocker are all all-stars, from front desk to bellhops to wait staff at the breakfast buffet on the 4th floor. (Shoutout to sweet Gania!) Food and coffee at the breakfast are phenomenal. So glad we chose to include this!
Everyone on sta...
Read more
M H said...
Good location; dated room interior
Travelled on 05/2025
Perfect location but could do with a renovation. The AC had some funny behavior and the window couldnt be opened. And for the Five Stars the interior has clearly seen better days. In the end its Times Square NY I guess. Compared to other hotels in this category I have to say its not that convincing...
Excursion360376 said...
Exceptional hotel with extraordinary staff!
Travelled on 04/2025
An absolute gem of a hotel located in the middle of Manhattan. The location is excellent - incredibly walkable plus you are right next to a major subway stop/hub. However, the best part was how serene the hotel felt in the middle of it all. From the moment we walked in we immediately felt at ease. Every staff member was incredibly kind, friendly, and helpful and our room was luxurious and so big for NYC! We especiall...
Read more
Jenn G said...
Can't wait to stay again!
Travelled on 04/2025
What a delight to stay at The Knickerbocker! The rooms are designed so beautifully... simple and modern lines that somehow fit perfectly into the gorgeous historic building. The bathroom amenities make you feel like you're in a spa! A stone's throw from "The Crossroads of the World and yet quiet and restful inside. I will definitely stay there again when I need to do an overnight in the city!...